Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Coming from Vera

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • jbfoster
    replied
    Wow I will be 2 years old next month. Dam time goes by fast. No regret buying HS3. Looking forward to installing HS4. I will wait until it’s been out of beta.

    Jim


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

    Leave a comment:


  • simplextech
    replied
    Originally posted by cowinger View Post
    I answered your other thread. I have the hue motion sensors and I wouldn't buy any other zigbee sensor. They work great even through conbee, deconz and the jowihue plugin. What makes them better is their response time. They will reset back to no motion after 10 sec. and it doesn't seem to hurt the battery life. Also the light sensor is completely independent of motion. I have zooz ones that won't send a light value unless you trip the motion part.
    I have a Zooz 4-n-1 and zse09 and i think they are the same on not updating lux.

    Zigbee motion sensors are generally a lot better than z-wave on their speed and reset times. I think for sensors zigbee is probably better than z-wave but I'm not doing with my testing/comparison yet

    I really like the NYCE Ceiling motion sensors. They are super discreet and Zigbee so they are super fast response/reset times.

    Oh yeah I saw your other reply

    Leave a comment:


  • cowinger
    replied
    Originally posted by jeubanks View Post
    I don't know if the Edge has a Zigbee radio or not. Just using what I got.

    I have and use the JowiHue plugin and I think it's great with my Hue bridge and with my DeConz server. Nothing negative about it.

    As for Conbee/Raspbee with DeConz. I look at your list of things you have running. All lights and Philips. I have a ConBeee and DeConz setup and it works great with the two Osram/Lightify+ plus bulbs I have. It doesn't work with my NYCE motion sensors or door sensors or my old SmartThings multipurpose sensors or any other Zigbee device I have (lamp module for repeater). I'm hoping and waiting for the day more ZHA things are supported by DeConz and not just ZLL.

    Now on the FLIP side of what I just said. I really do want to try a Philips motion sensor. Three reasons.

    1. I have never tested them.
    2. I think they will work with JowiHue through the Hue bridge
    3. If they work and have excellent performance then they are cheaper than the NYCE sensors.
    I answered your other thread. I have the hue motion sensors and I wouldn't buy any other zigbee sensor. They work great even through conbee, deconz and the jowihue plugin. What makes them better is their response time. They will reset back to no motion after 10 sec. and it doesn't seem to hurt the battery life. Also the light sensor is completely independent of motion. I have zooz ones that won't send a light value unless you trip the motion part.

    Leave a comment:


  • simplextech
    replied
    Originally posted by cowinger View Post
    I saw in the list for the edge that there were some zigbee devices that were supposedly controllable by the edge but I am not sure about that. Does the edge even have a zigbee radio? I didn't think it did.
    Anyways have you thought about using the conbee and the jowihue plugin. I have a whole bunch of devices running off it. Osram adj. white, color; sengled, adj white; and philips motion sensors.
    I don't know if the Edge has a Zigbee radio or not. Just using what I got.

    I have and use the JowiHue plugin and I think it's great with my Hue bridge and with my DeConz server. Nothing negative about it.

    As for Conbee/Raspbee with DeConz. I look at your list of things you have running. All lights and Philips. I have a ConBeee and DeConz setup and it works great with the two Osram/Lightify+ plus bulbs I have. It doesn't work with my NYCE motion sensors or door sensors or my old SmartThings multipurpose sensors or any other Zigbee device I have (lamp module for repeater). I'm hoping and waiting for the day more ZHA things are supported by DeConz and not just ZLL.

    Now on the FLIP side of what I just said. I really do want to try a Philips motion sensor. Three reasons.

    1. I have never tested them.
    2. I think they will work with JowiHue through the Hue bridge
    3. If they work and have excellent performance then they are cheaper than the NYCE sensors.

    Leave a comment:


  • cowinger
    replied
    Originally posted by jeubanks View Post
    I have a Vera Plus (2 actually).

    The Vera Plus support Zigbee (so does the Vera Secure). Anyways. They work with a limited (check the vera supported list) number of zigbee devices. I got lucky in that coming from Vera all my zigbee was already working but would not work with HomeSeer.

    However Vera has a good HTTP API and So does HS3. So I used them. There's a couple of ways of doing this. It could also be done with the Vera MQTT app. I'm using it also for basic sensor data but not for motion sensors. For motion sensors I use Vera Scenes one for on one for off and they make a Lua call to the HS3 Json API that turns on/off a virtual device in HS3. From that point make events as normal for whatever you want that sensor used for.

    One thing I have to say is that Vera scene execution is very fast so it's almost like the sensors are native to HS3.

    The same thing can be done with switches as well, but I'm actually thinking of doing a plugin for that, but I go back and forth on that as I don't use zigbee switches except power plugs for repeaters. I only use zigbee sensors and the use of scenes for motion sensors and then mqtt for other things like temp/humidity is perfect through mqtt because I don't have the "instant" want for that data. A few milliseconds on receiving that data doesn't matter to me.
    I saw in the list for the edge that there were some zigbee devices that were supposedly controllable by the edge but I am not sure about that. Does the edge even have a zigbee radio? I didn't think it did.
    Anyways have you thought about using the conbee and the jowihue plugin. I have a whole bunch of devices running off it. Osram adj. white, color; sengled, adj white; and philips motion sensors.

    Leave a comment:


  • simplextech
    replied
    Originally posted by cowinger View Post
    John, Which of the vera's do you have. Did you connect it as a secondary controller or is that possible?
    I have a Vera Plus (2 actually).

    The Vera Plus support Zigbee (so does the Vera Secure). Anyways. They work with a limited (check the vera supported list) number of zigbee devices. I got lucky in that coming from Vera all my zigbee was already working but would not work with HomeSeer.

    However Vera has a good HTTP API and So does HS3. So I used them. There's a couple of ways of doing this. It could also be done with the Vera MQTT app. I'm using it also for basic sensor data but not for motion sensors. For motion sensors I use Vera Scenes one for on one for off and they make a Lua call to the HS3 Json API that turns on/off a virtual device in HS3. From that point make events as normal for whatever you want that sensor used for.

    One thing I have to say is that Vera scene execution is very fast so it's almost like the sensors are native to HS3.

    The same thing can be done with switches as well, but I'm actually thinking of doing a plugin for that, but I go back and forth on that as I don't use zigbee switches except power plugs for repeaters. I only use zigbee sensors and the use of scenes for motion sensors and then mqtt for other things like temp/humidity is perfect through mqtt because I don't have the "instant" want for that data. A few milliseconds on receiving that data doesn't matter to me.

    Leave a comment:


  • cowinger
    replied
    John, Which of the vera's do you have. Did you connect it as a secondary controller or is that possible?

    Leave a comment:


  • cowinger
    replied
    Originally posted by jeubanks View Post
    That's the problem with Vera...it's far to under-powered to really achieve what it could.

    But with no apps running and a clean install it makes for a good zigbee controller for HomeSeer!
    I have a Vera Edge that hasn't been powered up for a couple of years. How did you get it to do the zigbee devices. I currently use a conbee (which is limited on devices) and I am curious as to what devices the vera edge can control.

    Leave a comment:


  • onepointbrewing
    replied
    Originally posted by jeubanks View Post
    It cost me more trying everything else but I got a really good education out of it.
    Yep, its the only thing im thankful for Vera for..... putting up with a slow platform - not thankful for

    Leave a comment:


  • simplextech
    replied
    Yeah I've been around the block as well but I finally saw the light and came to HomeSeer. It cost me more trying everything else but I got a really good education out of it.

    Leave a comment:


  • brientim
    replied

    Leave a comment:


  • simplextech
    replied
    Originally posted by onepointbrewing View Post
    I also came over from Vera.

    I dont know why I took so long to see the light (as humans we are always scared of spending more on a system you already have).

    The speed of HS makes me laugh excitedly when I do something its so good. Its INSTANTANEOUS!

    For some reason I had accepted that Home Automation was always going to be slow, however now I see that Vera is just woefully - I mean WOEFULLY - underpowered.

    Thanks
    That's the problem with Vera...it's far to under-powered to really achieve what it could.

    But with no apps running and a clean install it makes for a good zigbee controller for HomeSeer!

    Leave a comment:


  • onepointbrewing
    replied
    I also came over from Vera.

    I dont know why I took so long to see the light (as humans we are always scared of spending more on a system you already have).

    The speed of HS makes me laugh excitedly when I do something its so good. Its INSTANTANEOUS!

    For some reason I had accepted that Home Automation was always going to be slow, however now I see that Vera is just woefully - I mean WOEFULLY - underpowered.

    Thanks

    Leave a comment:


  • jquincy
    replied
    I also came from VERA. You will be happy with the Homeseer decision. Welcome

    Leave a comment:


  • ServiceXp
    replied
    Welcome to the group. I also came from Vera..

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X